Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revision Previous revision
Next revision
Previous revision
ethics_morals_and_societal_implications_of_thelema [2026/10/03 12:49] – Add quotations verified against local source books, precise references and clearer explanation andyethics_morals_and_societal_implications_of_thelema [2026/10/04 14:41] (current) – Add verified public-domain illustrations and source context andy
Line 46: Line 46:
  
 For example, the discussion of education in section D condemns imposing tasks for which children are unsuited. Its stated criterion is fitness to their capacities. The discussion of building materials and food then applies a comparable test to things: defective construction and adulteration disregard the qualities required for the proposed use. The argument reaches familiar practical judgements through its account of nature and function, without reducing everything to the practitioner's immediate preference.(([[https://archive.org/download/CollectedPdfsByAleisterCrowley/AleisterCrowley-Duty.pdf|Duty]], sections A, B and D.)) For example, the discussion of education in section D condemns imposing tasks for which children are unsuited. Its stated criterion is fitness to their capacities. The discussion of building materials and food then applies a comparable test to things: defective construction and adulteration disregard the qualities required for the proposed use. The argument reaches familiar practical judgements through its account of nature and function, without reducing everything to the practitioner's immediate preference.(([[https://archive.org/download/CollectedPdfsByAleisterCrowley/AleisterCrowley-Duty.pdf|Duty]], sections A, B and D.))
 +
 +==== The four fields in one view ====
 +
 +The four divisions of Duty provide a second way to navigate the argument. They move from oneself to other individuals, mankind, and other beings and things. These are the essay's headings; the three kinds of ethical argument discussed above are an analytical distinction that can cut across them.
 +
 +The modern diagram keeps those two arrangements separate. A reader can locate a passage by its division without assuming that everything within that division uses only one kind of reasoning. It is a reading aid, not an illustration from a historical edition.(([[https://lib.oto-usa.org/crowley/essays/duty.html|Duty]], divisions A–D.))
 +
 +<WRAP centeralign>
 +{{:0:literature:duty-four-fields-cc0.svg?400|The four fields of Duty, shown in a modern CC0 reading diagram.}}
 +</WRAP>
 +
 +//The four fields of Duty, shown in a modern CC0 reading diagram.// Original modern explanatory diagram created for this wiki and dedicated to [[https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/|CC0]]. [[https://lib.oto-usa.org/crowley/essays/duty.html|Source context]]. Click to enlarge.
  
 ===== Learning from another person without surrendering judgement ===== ===== Learning from another person without surrendering judgement =====
Line 58: Line 70:
  
 The sources also contain tensions of rhetoric: compassion, elitism, joy, severity and non-interference are not expressed in one consistent register. A developed account of Thelemic ethics should preserve those tensions and identify which text is speaking. The [[magical_record|magical record]] provides a practical counterpart by making motives, actions and results available for later examination rather than relying entirely on retrospective self-justification. The sources also contain tensions of rhetoric: compassion, elitism, joy, severity and non-interference are not expressed in one consistent register. A developed account of Thelemic ethics should preserve those tensions and identify which text is speaking. The [[magical_record|magical record]] provides a practical counterpart by making motives, actions and results available for later examination rather than relying entirely on retrospective self-justification.
 +
 +===== Video: will, rights and responsibilities =====
 +
 +Matthew Szymanski, a Temple of the Silver Star Academic Track instructor, examines the ethical, psychological and practical dimensions of will in this class. Its stated subjects include individual rights and responsibilities, relationships with other beings, and influences from Taoism and Karma Yoga. These concerns connect directly with the article's reading of freedom, conduct and the effects of action on others.
 +
 +{{ youtube>l1K4cZCjhPc?full |Do What Thou Wilt: The Law of Liberty}}
 +
 +**Do What Thou Wilt: The Law of Liberty** — [[https://www.youtube.com/@TempleoftheSilverStar|Temple of the Silver Star]]; 1:44:15. [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l1K4cZCjhPc|Watch on YouTube]].
 +
 +
 +
 +
  
  • Last modified: 2026/10/03 12:49
  • by andy