Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revision Previous revision
Next revision
Previous revision
liber_ru [2026/09/30 10:01] – Expand historical context, structure, breath and spirit, source qualifications and original illustration. andyliber_ru [2026/10/04 14:47] (current) – Add verified public-domain illustrations and source context andy
Line 14: Line 14:
 ===== Place in the A∴A∴ literature ===== ===== Place in the A∴A∴ literature =====
  
-The 1913 [[aa_syllabus|syllabus]] includes Liber RV in Class D and describes it as a full instruction in pranayama. The text is also reproduced in [[magick_in_theory_and_practice|Magick in Theory and Practice]], pp. 405–409, the edition used for the detailed references here. Its appearance in the earlier syllabus establishes that the title and curricular role predate that later printing. It does not, by itself, establish every detail of the publication history of the surviving text.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/1.10/a-syllabus-of-the-official-instructions-of-aa_low.pdf|1913 syllabus]], p. 52.))+Liber RV appeared in //The Equinox// I:7 (1912), pp. 59–67, with a **Class B** classification leaf. The 1913 [[aa_syllabus|syllabus]] subsequently lists it in **Class D** and describes it as a full instruction in pranayama. The later reproduction in [[magick_in_theory_and_practice|Magick in Theory and Practice]], pp. 405–409, supplies many of the references below; the quotations identify the earlier printing explicitly. The sources establish a difference in classification, without explaining its cause.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/1.7/liber-rv_low.pdf|Liber RV, 1912 printing]], classification leaf and pp. 61–67; [[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/1.10/a-syllabus-of-the-official-instructions-of-aa_low.pdf|1913 syllabus]], p. 52.))
  
 Its references to the Zelator’s Practicus place instruction and judgement within a teacher–pupil relationship. The text presupposes earlier work in posture and breathing, rather than introducing those subjects from the beginning. [[one_star_in_sight|One Star in Sight]] and [[liber_graduum|Liber Graduum]] provide a broader setting for these grade names; the presence of a grade name is not evidence that every unusual experience mentioned here establishes that grade. Its references to the Zelator’s Practicus place instruction and judgement within a teacher–pupil relationship. The text presupposes earlier work in posture and breathing, rather than introducing those subjects from the beginning. [[one_star_in_sight|One Star in Sight]] and [[liber_graduum|Liber Graduum]] provide a broader setting for these grade names; the presence of a grade name is not evidence that every unusual experience mentioned here establishes that grade.
Line 25: Line 25:
  
 Distinguishing observation from interpretation is essential when reading the work. A record of a sensation, a movement or an altered state does not automatically establish the esoteric explanation attached to it. Liber RV repeatedly asks for investigation, but its printed instructions do not provide a completed experimental study that settles those questions. Distinguishing observation from interpretation is essential when reading the work. A record of a sensation, a movement or an altered state does not automatically establish the esoteric explanation attached to it. Liber RV repeatedly asks for investigation, but its printed instructions do not provide a completed experimental study that settles those questions.
 +
 +The introduction to the proposed relationships is worth preserving exactly:
 +
 +> Let him investigate the following statements, and prepare a careful record of research.
 +
 +— Aleister Crowley, //Liber RV vel Spiritus//.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/1.7/liber-rv_low.pdf|Liber RV vel Spiritus]], §3, The Equinox I:7 (1912), p. 61.))
 +
 +The grammatical object is a set of statements to be investigated. The text supplies claims and an instruction to record inquiry, while leaving the completed observations to the student. A description of the published book should retain that distinction: its experimental vocabulary is evidence of an intended method, not a substitute for the results of carrying it out.
  
 ===== How the practices are organised ===== ===== How the practices are organised =====
Line 47: Line 55:
  
 The relation to Astarte also prevents a purely mechanical reading. A change of breathing pattern is not the whole religious operation when the participant is directing devotion towards a deity. Conversely, the presence of devotional language does not make the physiological claims established facts. The relation to Astarte also prevents a purely mechanical reading. A change of breathing pattern is not the whole religious operation when the participant is directing devotion towards a deity. Conversely, the presence of devotional language does not make the physiological claims established facts.
 +
 +==== Rhythmic phrases in musical notation ====
 +
 +Book 4's chapter on pranayama and mantrayoga supplies a visual comparison: it prints repeated phrases with musical notation. The notation makes rhythm a visible feature of the mantra, alongside the words and their associations.
 +
 +This page belongs to Book 4, Part I, not to the numbered instructions of Liber RV. It illustrates the parallel discussion of repeated speech, and should not be taken as a complete breathing schedule or as notation for all the walking and dancing practices described here. See [[pranayama|pranayama]] for the individual examples in their chapter setting.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/book4/1/pranayama;-and-its-parallel-in-speech-mantrayoga_low.pdf|Book 4, Part I]], p. 34.))
 +
 +<WRAP centeralign>
 +{{:0:literature:pranayama-book4-1912.png?520|Mantra examples in musical notation, Book 4, Part I (1912), p. 34.}}
 +</WRAP>
 +
 +//Mantra examples in musical notation, Book 4, Part I (1912), p. 34.// [[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/book4/1/pranayama;-and-its-parallel-in-speech-mantrayoga_low.pdf|Source and original]]. **Public domain:** original published 1912. Click to enlarge.
  
 ===== Bodily signs and extraordinary claims ===== ===== Bodily signs and extraordinary claims =====
Line 66: Line 86:
 ===== The closing qualification ===== ===== The closing qualification =====
  
-The last paragraph tells the Zelator not to grant automatic credit to the work’s statements and adds that advice suited to an average case may be wholly inappropriate to an individual. This conclusion is central to the document’s stance towards its own authority. It places a demand for critical judgement beside the preceding sequence of confident instructions.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/book4/3/liber-rv-vel-spiritus_low.pdf|Liber RV]], §17, p. 409.))+The final paragraph qualifies the authority of the entire instruction: 
 + 
 +> Let the Zelator attach no credit to any statements that may have been made throughout the course of this instruction, and reflect that even the counsel which We have given as suitable to the average case may be entirely unsuitable to his own. 
 + 
 +— Aleister Crowley, //Liber RV vel Spiritus//.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/1.7/liber-rv_low.pdf|Liber RV vel Spiritus]], §17, The Equinox I:7 (1912), p. 67.)) 
 + 
 +The first clause concerns accepting statements; the second concerns applying advice. They address different mistakes: treating a printed claim as established evidence, and treating a general prescription as suitable for every person. Because the qualification refers to the whole preceding course, it also bears on the spectacular bodily claims earlier in the text. It should accompany those claims when the work is summarised, rather than disappear when an isolated passage is quoted.
  
 For a wider account of Crowley’s yoga vocabulary, see [[book_4|Book 4]], [[eight_lectures_on_yoga|Eight Lectures on Yoga]] and [[pranayama|pranayama]]. Liber RV remains the specialised source: it shows how observation, bodily discipline, movement and devotion are brought together, while also preserving assumptions and risky practices that require clear historical framing. For a wider account of Crowley’s yoga vocabulary, see [[book_4|Book 4]], [[eight_lectures_on_yoga|Eight Lectures on Yoga]] and [[pranayama|pranayama]]. Liber RV remains the specialised source: it shows how observation, bodily discipline, movement and devotion are brought together, while also preserving assumptions and risky practices that require clear historical framing.
 +
 +===== Video: the setting of breath practice =====
 +
 +David Shoemaker's Living Thelema presentation introduces asana and pranayama, the disciplines that provide the setting for Liber RV. The [[https://livingthelema.com/living-thelema/resources/|programme's resource list]] expressly includes this instruction. The recording offers an introduction to the practices; the article above follows the more specialised text's progression through observation, rhythm and aspiration.
 +
 +{{ youtube>XiVBs5RX0yg?full |Living Thelema - Asana and Pranayama}}
 +
 +**Living Thelema - Asana and Pranayama** — [[https://www.youtube.com/@speechinthesilence|Speech in the Silence Podcast]]; 23:56. [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XiVBs5RX0yg|Watch on YouTube]].
  
 ===== Sources ===== ===== Sources =====
   * [[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/book4/3/liber-rv-vel-spiritus_low.pdf|Liber RV vel Spiritus in Magick in Theory and Practice]], pp. 405–409.   * [[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/book4/3/liber-rv-vel-spiritus_low.pdf|Liber RV vel Spiritus in Magick in Theory and Practice]], pp. 405–409.
   * [[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/1.10/a-syllabus-of-the-official-instructions-of-aa_low.pdf|A Syllabus of the Official Instructions of A∴A∴ (1913)]], Class D entry on p. 52.   * [[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/1.10/a-syllabus-of-the-official-instructions-of-aa_low.pdf|A Syllabus of the Official Instructions of A∴A∴ (1913)]], Class D entry on p. 52.
 +
 +
  
  • Last modified: 2026/09/30 10:01
  • by andy