Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revision Previous revision
Next revision
Previous revision
meditation [2026/10/01 06:34] – Expand article with primary-source analysis, cross-references and a credited public-domain illustration. andymeditation [2026/10/04 09:55] (current) – Add source-checked public-domain diagrams with edition-specific reading notes andy
Line 39: Line 39:
  
 ===== Concentration and the problem of interruption ===== ===== Concentration and the problem of interruption =====
-The chapter on dharana makes the instability of attention an object of observation. A selected image or idea repeatedly changes, disappears or is displaced. Recognising these interruptions exposes the difference between intending to concentrate and maintaining concentration.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/book4/1/dharana_low.pdf|Book 4, Part I, “Dharana”]].))+In the chapter on dharana, Crowley asks the reader to consider a visualised white cross. The imagined bars move, change proportion or acquire patterns; the whole image changes colour, size or distance. He concludes: 
 + 
 +> There is no conceivable change of which it is incapable. Not to mention its total disappearance, and replacement by something altogether different! 
 + 
 +— Aleister Crowley, //Book 4, Part I//.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/book4/1/dharana_low.pdf|Book 4, Part I]], chapter V, “Dharana,” p. 56; “it” refers to the chosen visualised object.)) 
 + 
 +The example makes the instability of attention observable. Recognising such interruptions exposes the difference between intending to concentrate and maintaining concentration. It also gives the [[magical_record|record]] something more precise to preserve than a general judgement that a session went well or badly.
  
 //Liber E// develops this concern through a record of practice. Duration, conditions and interruptions provide material for comparison across sessions. The point is not to create an impressive diary of successes. An accurate account of difficulties is more informative than an attainment label unsupported by description. A session may reveal recurrent patterns even when it does not meet the practitioner’s initial expectations.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/1.1/liber-exercitiorum_low.pdf|Liber E]], sections I and V.)) //Liber E// develops this concern through a record of practice. Duration, conditions and interruptions provide material for comparison across sessions. The point is not to create an impressive diary of successes. An accurate account of difficulties is more informative than an attainment label unsupported by description. A session may reveal recurrent patterns even when it does not meet the practitioner’s initial expectations.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/1.1/liber-exercitiorum_low.pdf|Liber E]], sections I and V.))
  
 The [[magical_record|magical record]] therefore mediates between intention and retrospective interpretation. It allows a later reader to ask what actually happened, how long it lasted and what else might account for it. Repeated observations are more useful than memories selected because they fit a favoured theory. The [[magical_record|magical record]] therefore mediates between intention and retrospective interpretation. It allows a later reader to ask what actually happened, how long it lasted and what else might account for it. Repeated observations are more useful than memories selected because they fit a favoured theory.
 +
 +==== Observation and control in the original diagram ====
 +
 +The preceding chapter on pratyahara uses two curves to distinguish noticing thoughts from controlling them. EF represents observation, while BD represents control; the dotted distances between them indicate the student’s dissatisfaction. Crowley explains the latter directly:
 +
 +> The height of the perpendiculars HI indicates the dissatisfaction of the student with his power of control.
 +
 +— Aleister Crowley, //Book 4//, Part I, “Pratyahara,” p. 49.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/book4/1/pratyahara_low.pdf|Book 4, Part I, Pratyahara]], p. 49.))
 +
 +This is a schematic teaching diagram rather than measured experimental data. Its point is that learning to notice distractions can initially outpace learning to restrain them, making practice feel less successful even as observation improves.
 +
 +<WRAP centeralign>
 +{{:0:literature:book4_attention-1912.png?560|Book 4, Part I (1912), p. 49: the original diagram of observation, control and dissatisfaction, with Crowley’s explanatory key.}}
 +</WRAP>
 +
 +//Book 4, Part I (1912), p. 49: the original diagram of observation, control and dissatisfaction, with Crowley’s explanatory key.// [[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/book4/1/pratyahara_low.pdf|Source facsimile: Keep Silence]]. **Public domain:** original published in 1912. Click the image to enlarge.
  
 ===== Dhyana and samadhi ===== ===== Dhyana and samadhi =====
Line 56: Line 78:
  
 For the larger instructional setting, consult [[one_star_in_sight|One Star in Sight]], the [[aa_syllabus|A∴A∴ syllabus]] and [[liber_collegii_sancti|Liber Collegii Sancti]]. Together they show how bodily discipline, concentration, visionary work and the record belong to an extended course of study. For the larger instructional setting, consult [[one_star_in_sight|One Star in Sight]], the [[aa_syllabus|A∴A∴ syllabus]] and [[liber_collegii_sancti|Liber Collegii Sancti]]. Together they show how bodily discipline, concentration, visionary work and the record belong to an extended course of study.
 +
 +===== Video: a historical influence on Crowley’s yoga =====
 +
 +Keith Edward Cantú discusses Sri Sabhapati Swami's techniques and their reception in Theosophical and Thelemic settings in this Ordo Templi Orientis USA presentation. The programme includes their integration into Crowley's magick. It provides historical context for the article's treatment of meditation as part of Crowley's particular synthesis, helping readers distinguish that synthesis from a uniform account of Indian yoga traditions.
 +
 +{{ youtube>RgtIT8r1B-8?full |Dr  Keith Cantú, Sri Sabhapaty Swami, Theosophy, and Thelema}}
 +
 +**Dr  Keith Cantú, Sri Sabhapaty Swami, Theosophy, and Thelema** — [[https://www.youtube.com/@OrdoTempliOrientisUSA|Ordo Templi Orientis USA]]; 1:19:41. [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RgtIT8r1B-8|Watch on YouTube]].
 +
 +
 +
 +
  
  • Last modified: 2026/10/01 06:34
  • by andy