Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revision Previous revision
Next revision
Previous revision
middle_pillar_meditation [2026/10/02 17:58] – Develop explanations and source examples; credited public-domain illustrations (batch 23) andymiddle_pillar_meditation [2026/10/04 07:12] (current) – Add matched video with channel credit and reading context andy
Line 44: Line 44:
  
 Crowley's [[liber_e|Liber E]] offers another useful comparison through its emphasis on concentration and keeping a record. Applied as a method of study, a record can distinguish the duration and sequence of an exercise from the practitioner's explanation of its effects. It also makes a change of method visible: a different circulation, added name or altered order should be noted rather than retrospectively treated as the same attempt. Crowley's [[liber_e|Liber E]] offers another useful comparison through its emphasis on concentration and keeping a record. Applied as a method of study, a record can distinguish the duration and sequence of an exercise from the practitioner's explanation of its effects. It also makes a change of method visible: a different circulation, added name or altered order should be noted rather than retrospectively treated as the same attempt.
 +
 +Liber E makes room for emotional experience within its recording method:
 +
 +> The more scientific the record is, the better. Yet the emotions should be noted, as being some of the conditions.
 +
 +— Aleister Crowley, //Liber E vel Exercitiorum//.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/book4/3/liber-e-vel-exercitiorum_low.pdf|Liber E vel Exercitiorum]], I:9, reprinted in Magick in Theory and Practice, p. 368.))
 +
 +Applied to a study of the Middle Pillar, this suggests recording an experience’s felt character alongside the sequence of centres and names. A calm or excited state can affect the session and its later recollection; acknowledging it gives a fuller account of the circumstances. This is a comparison of methods, not evidence that Crowley authored Regardie’s exercise. The distinction lets his instructions contribute to how a practice is studied without changing its attribution.
  
 ===== The axis, the complete Tree and Daath ===== ===== The axis, the complete Tree and Daath =====
Line 59: Line 67:
  
 The symbolic reading and the experiential report can then be considered separately. A practitioner may report a vivid sensation of light or movement; an author may explain it through a theory of spiritual force or psychology. Recording both without merging them preserves what was experienced and how it was interpreted. See [[magical_record|the magical record]] and [[source_guide|the source guide]] for this approach to practice and texts. The symbolic reading and the experiential report can then be considered separately. A practitioner may report a vivid sensation of light or movement; an author may explain it through a theory of spiritual force or psychology. Recording both without merging them preserves what was experienced and how it was interpreted. See [[magical_record|the magical record]] and [[source_guide|the source guide]] for this approach to practice and texts.
 +
 +A further comparison concerns the time allowed for interpretation:
 +
 +> It is desirable that the student should never attach to any result the importance which it at first seems to possess.
 +
 +— Aleister Crowley, //Liber O vel Manus et Sagittae//.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/book4/3/liber-o-vel-manus-et-sagittae_low.pdf|Liber O vel Manus et Sagittae]], I:5, concluding sentence; reprinted in Magick in Theory and Practice, p. 376.))
 +
 +The sentence asks the student to reconsider an initial estimate of significance. For a repeated visualisation, this creates room to compare sessions before treating one unusually vivid effect as definitive. The record can retain the original impression and add a dated later assessment, preserving both rather than silently rewriting the first experience. That approach also helps when comparing variants: the technique used, the reported effect and the importance assigned to it remain separately traceable.
 +
 +===== Video: the Middle Pillar in Living Thelema =====
 +
 +David Shoemaker discusses the Middle Pillar exercise in programme 44 of Living Thelema. This contemporary teaching presentation accompanies the article's account of the central axis, visualised stations and circulation of light. Compare it with the published versions discussed above, keeping the distinction between the exercise, the complete Tree of Life and the details of a particular teacher's method.
 +
 +{{ youtube>35iG6cn3bDo?full |The Middle Pillar Exercise}}
 +
 +**The Middle Pillar Exercise** — [[https://www.youtube.com/@livingthelema5221|Living Thelema]]; 25:31. [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=35iG6cn3bDo|Watch on YouTube]].
 +
 +
  
  
  • Last modified: 2026/10/02 17:58
  • by andy