Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revision Previous revision
Next revision
Previous revision
tarot_and_the_thoth_tarot_deck [2026/10/02 17:30] – Develop article with sourced examples, clarify interpretation, and preserve image credits (batch 22) andytarot_and_the_thoth_tarot_deck [2026/11/08 18:07] (current) – Index the numbered Tarot card studies andy
Line 11: Line 11:
  
 ===== The Crowley–Harris collaboration ===== ===== The Crowley–Harris collaboration =====
-The Warburg Institute dates the project to **1937–43**. Crowley's bibliographical note describes an initial plan for relatively limited revision of an inherited deck. Harris encouraged a more extensive undertaking, and an anticipated three months of work became approximately five years. Crowley acknowledges her development of pictures from rough sketches, verbal descriptions and earlier models, including repeated repainting of individual cards.(([[https://warburg.sas.ac.uk/news-events/blogs/tarot-origins-afterlives-conversation-director-co-curator-bill-sherman|Warburg Institute, Tarot: Origins & Afterlives]], conversation with Bill Sherman, 16 April 2025; [[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/thoth-book/bibliographical-note_low.pdf|The Book of Thoth, bibliographical note]], pp. xi–xii.))+The Warburg Institute dates the project to **1937–43**. The book’s bibliographical note, signed “S. H. Soror I.W.E.”, describes an initial plan for relatively limited revision of an inherited deck. Harris encouraged a more extensive undertaking, and an anticipated three months of work became approximately five years. The note credits Harris’s development of pictures from rough sketches, verbal descriptions and earlier models, including repeated repainting of individual cards.(([[https://warburg.sas.ac.uk/news-events/blogs/tarot-origins-afterlives-conversation-director-co-curator-bill-sherman|Warburg Institute, Tarot: Origins & Afterlives]], conversation with Bill Sherman, 16 April 2025; [[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/thoth-book/bibliographical-note_low.pdf|The Book of Thoth, bibliographical note]], pp. xi–xii.))
  
 Harris's contribution was therefore creative as well as technical. Crowley supplied a symbolic programme and explanations; she determined how those ideas could become coherent paintings. Revisions were part of the collaboration, and the final images should not be described as coloured copies of a complete design that already existed independently of her work. Harris's contribution was therefore creative as well as technical. Crowley supplied a symbolic programme and explanations; she determined how those ideas could become coherent paintings. Revisions were part of the collaboration, and the final images should not be described as coloured copies of a complete design that already existed independently of her work.
Line 43: Line 43:
  
 Crowley also interprets //Liber AL// I:57 as requiring a revised relationship between **the Emperor** and **the Star**. In the Thoth system the Emperor, IV, is assigned to **Tzaddi** and Aries; the Star, XVII, to **He** and Aquarius. The cards retain their familiar numbers while their Hebrew-letter assignments differ from the earlier Golden Dawn arrangement. Crowley's account treats the solution as confirmation of his religious understanding; that is his interpretation of the correspondence, rather than an independently established historical proof.((//The Book of Thoth//, Part I, pp. 9–10, and Part II, Atu IV and XVII.)) Crowley also interprets //Liber AL// I:57 as requiring a revised relationship between **the Emperor** and **the Star**. In the Thoth system the Emperor, IV, is assigned to **Tzaddi** and Aries; the Star, XVII, to **He** and Aquarius. The cards retain their familiar numbers while their Hebrew-letter assignments differ from the earlier Golden Dawn arrangement. Crowley's account treats the solution as confirmation of his religious understanding; that is his interpretation of the correspondence, rather than an independently established historical proof.((//The Book of Thoth//, Part I, pp. 9–10, and Part II, Atu IV and XVII.))
 +
 +Crowley introduces the Aeon card with an explicit defence of revision:
 +
 +> In this card it has been necessary to depart completely from the tradition of the cards, in order to carry on that tradition.
 +
 +— Aleister Crowley, //The Book of Thoth//.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/thoth-book/part-two-the-atu-(keys-or-trumps)_low.pdf|The Book of Thoth]], part II, “XX. The Aeon” (1944), p. 115.))
 +
 +The two uses of “tradition” point to a distinction between retaining an inherited design and continuing what he regards as its function. His subsequent account describes the older resurrection scene before turning to the Stele of Revealing and the new aeon. The change is therefore justified through his religious reading of history. It does not imply that every older detail was unknown to the designers; the explanation makes deliberate departure part of their programme.
 +
 +===== Reading the trumps beside Liber 231 =====
 +There is an earlier Crowley text for every trump. In 1912 //Liber 231// presented twenty-two numbered passages, two sets of sigils and a table naming their genii. The [[liber_231_illustrated_index|illustrated index]] lets a reader choose any trump, inspect the two cells bearing its letter and open its card study. Each card study now includes the 1912 passage alongside the account of the Crowley–Harris design.
 +
 +Start with the Empress. Verse 3 compares her with a pearl seeking Seventy to her Four. Daleth is four and Ayin is seventy. The plate also directs the reader from Daleth to Ayin. This gives the image of desire a route through the printed correspondence itself. [[thoth_empress|The Empress and the pearl]] · [[liber_231_illustrated_index#daleth|The two Daleth sigils]].
 +
 +> the Father of all issued as a mighty wheel
 +
 +— Aleister Crowley, //Liber CCXXXI//, verse 10, //The Equinox// I:7 (1912), p. 72. [[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/1.7/liber-ccxxxi_low.pdf#page=5|The wheel and its three figures]].
 +
 +{{:0:literature:l231-1912-10-kaph.png?610|The Kaph sigils in the 1912 printing. The wheel in the left cell has six spokes.}}
 +
 +//Kaph, compared with the later Fortune card.// The verse describes the beings on the rim of a wheel. The Mercurial sigil gives the wheel six spokes, while the Thoth design gives it ten. This is a case where editions answer a simple visual question differently. Two more routes bring the editions together:
 +
 +  * Follow [[thoth_moon|the scarab in the Moon]] into [[thoth_sun|the unclouded Sun]]. In both books the emerging sun connects the consecutive trumps.
 +  * Follow the [[thoth_empress|Empress]], [[thoth_hanged_man|Hanged Man]] and [[thoth_universe|Universe]] as a family group under Life in the [[qabalah_of_nine_chambers#how_life_groups_three_trumps|Nine Chambers note]]. This reading crosses the numerical order of the deck.
  
 ===== The court cards ===== ===== The court cards =====
Line 55: Line 79:
  
 The descriptive titles likewise require context. **Ruin**, the Ten of Swords, is not a universal prediction that a person's life will end in disaster. It names a particular symbolic condition within a system and a reading. Crowley's own discussions frequently complicate a simple division between good and bad cards, including the possibility of change after exhaustion or collapse. The descriptive titles likewise require context. **Ruin**, the Ten of Swords, is not a universal prediction that a person's life will end in disaster. It names a particular symbolic condition within a system and a reading. Crowley's own discussions frequently complicate a simple division between good and bad cards, including the possibility of change after exhaustion or collapse.
 +
 +For a card-by-card comparison, use [[tarot_small_cards|the index of the thirty-six numbered cards]]. Read across the [[tarot_sixes|Sixes]] to see how one place on the Tree gives rise to Victory, Pleasure, Science and Success; each study prints the older titles beside Crowley’s and reproduces the corresponding lines of the 1912 inventory.
 +
 +==== An earlier table of suit correspondences ====
 +
 +The 1909 table shows the astrological glyphs attached to the numbered Wands and Cups before the Crowley–Harris deck was made. The second row pairs Wands with Mars in Aries and Cups with Venus in Cancer. The historical titles must be read as those of this printing: for example, the Three of Wands is “Established Strength” here, while the later Thoth card is Virtue. The image documents an earlier stage of the correspondence scheme, rather than supplying a replacement list of Thoth card titles.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/777/table-of-correspondences_low.pdf|777]], p. 27, columns CXXXIII–CXXXIV; [[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/thoth-book/part-iv-the-small-cards_low.pdf|The Book of Thoth]], part IV, “Virtue. Three of Wands”.))
 +
 +<WRAP centeralign>
 +{{:0:literature:777-wands-cups-table-1909.png?560|777 (1909), p. 27, upper table: Wands and Cups. Original planetary and zodiacal glyphs accompany the earlier card titles.}}
 +</WRAP>
 +
 +//777 (1909), p. 27, upper table: Wands and Cups. Original planetary and zodiacal glyphs accompany the earlier card titles.// [[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/777/table-of-correspondences_low.pdf|Source facsimile: Keep Silence]]. **Public domain:** original page published in 1909. Click the image to enlarge.
  
 ===== The Lovers and Art: an alchemical pair ===== ===== The Lovers and Art: an alchemical pair =====
Line 74: Line 110:
  
 For study, it is helpful to compare one group at a time: all four Aces, the four cards of a single number, or a pair such as the Lovers and Art. Record the printed title and assignments before adding a personal association. This makes it possible to distinguish the deck's stated scheme from a later interpretation and to notice when an interpretation changes. For study, it is helpful to compare one group at a time: all four Aces, the four cards of a single number, or a pair such as the Lovers and Art. Record the printed title and assignments before adding a personal association. This makes it possible to distinguish the deck's stated scheme from a later interpretation and to notice when an interpretation changes.
 +
 +Crowley also qualifies the completeness of the commentary:
 +
 +> The student of the Tarot must not therefore expect to find anything beyond a careful selection of the facts about any given card, a selection made for a quite definite magical purpose.
 +
 +— Aleister Crowley, //The Book of Thoth//.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/thoth-book/part-one-the-theory-of-the-tarot_low.pdf|The Book of Thoth]], part I, discussion immediately preceding “The Roman Numbers of the Trumps” (1944), p. 38.))
 +
 +The preceding analogy compares different maps of the same country: a geological map and a strategic map select different information because they answer different needs. Applied to a card, this makes purpose part of the explanation of its attributions. The next paragraph nevertheless asks the student to attend to the various correspondences, since each modifies the image and its use. Selection is thus acknowledged without reducing a card to one keyword.
  
 ===== Occult ancestry and documented history ===== ===== Occult ancestry and documented history =====
Line 79: Line 123:
  
 See also [[liber_777|777]], [[the_kabbalah_and_its_role_in_thelema|Qabalah]], [[thoth|Thoth]], [[babalon|Babalon]] and [[art_literature_and_music_in_thelema|art and literature in Thelema]]. See also [[liber_777|777]], [[the_kabbalah_and_its_role_in_thelema|Qabalah]], [[thoth|Thoth]], [[babalon|Babalon]] and [[art_literature_and_music_in_thelema|art and literature in Thelema]].
 +
 +===== Studies of individual cards =====
 +The [[article_index#the_trumps_in_order|trump directory]] links to studies of all twenty-two cards. Follow [[thoth_fool|the Fool]] and [[thoth_universe|the Universe]] to read the beginning and end together, or compare [[thoth_priestess|the Priestess]] with [[thoth_moon|the Moon]] to trace two different lunar paths. For the smaller cards, start with [[tarot_aces|the Aces]] or use the suit tables in the [[article_index#tarot_studies|Tarot directory]].
 +
 +===== Video: colour as a language in the Thoth Tarot =====
 +
 +Scott Wilde examines colour symbolism in the Crowley–Harris paintings in this lecture recorded at Horizon Lodge on 14 November 2023. The programme moves from the history of occult colour systems to the four scales and then to individual Thoth cards. The card discussion begins around 39:31, making this a useful visual companion to the account of the deck's symbolic design.
 +
 +{{ youtube>WEfAvdQgEsY?full |The Magick of Color (The Use of Color as a Language in the Thoth Tarot)}}
 +
 +**The Magick of Color (The Use of Color as a Language in the Thoth Tarot)** — [[https://www.youtube.com/@horizon-oto|Horizon, Ordo Templi Orientis]]; 1:33:17. [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WEfAvdQgEsY|Watch on YouTube]].
  
  • Last modified: 2026/10/02 17:30
  • by andy