Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revision Previous revision
Next revision
Previous revision
thoth [2026/10/01 09:17] – Expand article with primary sources, historical context, cross-links and credited public-domain illustration where available. andythoth [2026/11/08 17:46] (current) – Expand the Liber 231 references with original quotations, illustrations and links to the card studies. andy
Line 19: Line 19:
  
 The variety of roles need not be reduced to one abstract “meaning.” Writing, calendrical reckoning and adjudication are related activities, but an amulet, a temple image and a funerary papyrus give them different emphases. The text or object being discussed determines which function is in the foreground. The variety of roles need not be reduced to one abstract “meaning.” Writing, calendrical reckoning and adjudication are related activities, but an amulet, a temple image and a funerary papyrus give them different emphases. The text or object being discussed determines which function is in the foreground.
 +
 +===== The baboon and the working scribe =====
 +<WRAP right 260px>
 +{{:0:literature:met-544748.jpg?250|A scribe with the baboon form of Thoth on his back, ca. 1300–1080 BCE. Metropolitan Museum of Art, 29.2.16.}}
 +
 +//A scribe with the baboon form of Thoth on his back, ca. 1300–1080 BCE. Metropolitan Museum of Art, 29.2.16.// [[https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/544748|Source and original]]. **Public domain.** [[https://www.metmuseum.org/hubs/open-access|Rights information (CC0)]].
 +</WRAP>
 +
 +
 +
 +A small granodiorite statue in the Met, 29.2.16, joins a human scribe to a baboon seated on his back. The museum dates it to about 1300–1080 BCE and identifies the baboon as Thoth. Unlike the ibis-headed statuette, this composition shows god and human practitioner together. The relationship between scribal work and divine patronage becomes visible in the arrangement of the two figures.(([[https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/544748|Statue of a scribe with a baboon]], Metropolitan Museum of Art.))
 +
 +The comparison is useful because it makes clear that a divine animal need not stand alone. A single statue can express both a person's activity and the power associated with that activity. This differs from interpreting the baboon merely as an alternative animal label for the same god. Its position in this composition creates a relationship with the scribe beneath it.
 +
 +===== Speech on the solar journey =====
 +[[liber_resh|Liber Resh]] places Tahuti at the prow of the solar bark, with Ra-Hoor at the helm. The same arrangement recurs through the four adorations, although the solar form addressed changes from Ra to Ahathoor, Tum and Khephra. Tahuti's place is therefore part of a repeated dramatic setting for the sun's journey.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/1.6/liber-resh_low.pdf|Liber Resh]], sections 1–4.))
 +
 +The names work together: the changing solar form marks a phase of the cycle, while the recurring figures give the cycle continuity. This is more specific than saying that Thoth represents knowledge everywhere in Crowley's rituals. In Resh, the reader encounters him in an imagined vessel and an ordered movement through the day.
 +
 +That repeated public text also provides a point of comparison with Liber Israfel. Resh places Tahuti within an adoration; Israfel makes his wisdom and utterance the explicit object of invocation. The latter moves toward a speaker addressing an audience. The former closes its adorations with silence and meditation. In both cases speech has a structured beginning and ending, and divine names help organise what occurs between them.
 +
 +<WRAP right 390px>
 +{{:0:literature:resh-solar-cycle-cc0.svg?380|The four adorations of Liber Resh: changing solar forms, with Tahuti at the prow and Ra-Hoor at the helm throughout.}}
 +
 +//The four adorations of Liber Resh: changing solar forms, with Tahuti at the prow and Ra-Hoor at the helm throughout.// Original explanatory diagram created for Thelemic Wiki and dedicated to the public domain under CC0. Based on [[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/1.6/liber-resh_low.pdf|Liber Resh, §§1–4]]. [[https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/|Rights information (CC0)]].
 +</WRAP>
 +
 +
 +The four stations make the repeated placement easy to follow. The diagram retains the names and facing directions given in Resh; its simple vessel is an explanatory symbol rather than a copy of an Egyptian artefact.
  
 ===== Tahuti and the power of utterance ===== ===== Tahuti and the power of utterance =====
Line 26: Line 55:
  
 The opening note says the work was formerly called //Anubis//. Reading that title without the actual invocation can therefore lead to a mistaken identification of its central god. The opening note says the work was formerly called //Anubis//. Reading that title without the actual invocation can therefore lead to a mistaken identification of its central god.
 +
 +The invocation distributes its claim across bodily sites:
 +
 +> The God who commands is in my mouth!
 +> The God of Wisdom is in my Heart!
 +> My tongue is the Sanctuary of Truth!
 +> And a God sitteth upon my lips.
 +
 +— Aleister Crowley, //Liber Israfel//.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/1.7/liber-israfel_low.pdf|Liber Israfel]], §10, The Equinox I:7 (1912), p. 25.))
 +
 +Command, wisdom and truth acquire places within the speaker. The succeeding declaration that the Word is accomplished daily extends this identification from the body to its asserted effects. Within the ceremony, these lines prepare the authority of the lection that follows. They present the speaker’s adopted divine voice; they should not be detached from that dramatic setting and used as independent guarantees that every subsequent utterance is true.
 +
 +===== Tahuti steps out of the silence =====
 +Tahuti has two places in //Liber 231//. He appears in the title as the god whose Atu, or trumps, Asar saw in Amennti. He then steps into the action himself. Verse 0 holds its figure in the secret place of thunder. In verse 1 the lightnings increase, the Lord Tahuti stands forth, and a voice becomes audible.
 +
 +> The Voice came from the Silence. Then the One ran and returned.
 +
 +— Aleister Crowley, //Liber CCXXXI//, verse 1, //The Equinox// I:7 (1912), p. 71. [[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/1.7/liber-ccxxxi_low.pdf#page=4|Read verses 0–1]].
 +
 +The voice has no quoted message. Crowley gives it a point of origin and immediately describes movement in two directions. Compare //Liber Israfel// earlier in the same issue, where a ritual speaker locates divine speech in his own mouth and on his tongue. One text lets a reader witness a voice emerging. The other gives a performer words to speak. [[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/1.7/liber-israfel_low.pdf|Liber Israfel, §10]].
 +
 +{{:0:literature:l231-1912-01-beth.png?600|Beth sigils and printed names. Three upright implements appear in the Mercurial cell on the left.}}
 +
 +//Beth, verse 1. The two devices and the line of names come from the 1912 plate and p. 73 respectively.// The name Baratchial belongs to the Beth row. Tahuti is the divine figure named in the verse. [[liber_231_illustrated_index#beth|Beth and the original name forms]] · [[thoth_magus|The Magus]].
  
 ===== Thoth and the Tarot ===== ===== Thoth and the Tarot =====
Line 31: Line 84:
  
 This distinction also clarifies the relationship between deity, book and deck. Thoth is an ancient god; the Crowley–Harris Tarot is a modern artistic and magical work; Crowley's book interprets that work. Calling all three “Thoth” without qualification can obscure which subject a source actually documents. This distinction also clarifies the relationship between deity, book and deck. Thoth is an ancient god; the Crowley–Harris Tarot is a modern artistic and magical work; Crowley's book interprets that work. Calling all three “Thoth” without qualification can obscure which subject a source actually documents.
 +
 +===== The Magus: communication and its distortions =====
 +The explanation of **The Magus (I)** in //The Book of Thoth// complicates a simple identification of Thoth with reliable knowledge. Crowley's Mercury includes wisdom and folly, truth and falsehood, the messenger and the trickster. Communication is powerful precisely because a message can transform what its recipient thinks, but that power does not guarantee fidelity to an original intention.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/thoth-book/part-two-the-atu-(keys-or-trumps)_low.pdf|The Book of Thoth, Part II]], “I. The Magus”, pp. 70–72.))
 +
 +Crowley interprets the ibis through concentration and links the writing implements to the transmission of wisdom. He gives the accompanying ape, or Cynocephalus, a different function: it represents distortion entering the utterance as it becomes manifest. These are components of his particular explanation of the trump. They do not establish that the baboon beside an ancient Egyptian scribe was originally intended to signify corrupted knowledge.
 +
 +That distinction matters especially when comparing the Tarot with the museum object illustrated above. A baboon can act as a manifestation or patronal presence of Thoth in an Egyptian setting, while Crowley uses a related figure in an argument about the risks of expression. The change of setting changes the relation between figure and meaning. Treating the pictures as a universal dictionary would suppress the very difference that makes comparison useful.
 +
 +===== The limits of a fixed picture =====
 +Crowley also acknowledges a difficulty in representing Mercury's continual movement through a static card. The picture can prompt recollection and thought, but cannot literally contain the activity it represents. This places a limit on the sufficiency of the illustration within his own account.((//The Book of Thoth//, “I. The Magus”.))
 +
 +For the study of Thoth, the passage opens a broader question about writing and religious images. A written name, an illustrated figure and a spoken invocation are different means of communication. Their connections can be traced, while their different capacities—and the possibility of misunderstanding—remain part of the subject itself.
 +
 +Crowley gives the card a deliberately modest description:
 +
 +> this picture is, therefore, hardly more than mnemonic jottings.
 +
 +— Aleister Crowley, //The Book of Thoth//.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/thoth-book/part-two-the-atu-(keys-or-trumps)_low.pdf|The Book of Thoth]], part II, “I. The Magus” (1944), p. 72; final clause of the sentence beginning “Yet no true image is possible at all”.))
 +
 +The clause concludes an argument that a still image contradicts Mercury’s perpetual motion. A mnemonic aid prompts the viewer to recover relations that the surface cannot fully enact. This accounts for the importance of the accompanying prose: the painting initiates a process of recollection and interpretation. It also explains why a single attribute, whether ibis head or writing implement, cannot by itself exhaust the Magus’s meaning.
 +
 +==== More than one position in the correspondence tables ====
 +
 +The same caution applies to tabulated names. In 777, column XX assigns Thoth to keys 8 and 12. Column XIX gives Anubis at 8, but Thoth and Cynocephalus at 12, and also includes Thoth among the names at key 2. The headings distinguish a selected group of gods from a separate practical attribution.
 +
 +A single equation such as “Thoth equals one number” would hide these differences. The relevant entry is a relationship within a named column and row. Read in this way, the table complements the article’s discussion of writing, speech and the Tarot without claiming that every appearance of Thoth must have the same function.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/777/table-of-correspondences_low.pdf|777]], p. 6, columns XIX–XX, keys 2, 8 and 12.))
 +
 +<WRAP centeralign>
 +{{:0:literature:777-egyptian-columns-xix-xx-1909.png?500|777 (1909), p. 6: columns XX and XIX, with their original headings and the key numbers at the right. This crop omits the separate column XXI.}}
 +</WRAP>
 +
 +//777 (1909), p. 6: columns XX and XIX, with their original headings and the key numbers at the right. This crop omits the separate column XXI.// [[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/777/table-of-correspondences_low.pdf|Source facsimile: Keep Silence]]. **Public domain:** original published in 1909. Click the image to enlarge.
  
 ===== Further reading ===== ===== Further reading =====
 See [[liber_israfel|Liber Israfel]], [[the_book_of_thoth|The Book of Thoth]], [[tarot_and_the_thoth_tarot_deck|the Thoth Tarot]] and [[egyptian_gods_summary|Egyptian gods and Thelemic adaptations]]. See [[liber_israfel|Liber Israfel]], [[the_book_of_thoth|The Book of Thoth]], [[tarot_and_the_thoth_tarot_deck|the Thoth Tarot]] and [[egyptian_gods_summary|Egyptian gods and Thelemic adaptations]].
  
  • Last modified: 2026/10/01 09:17
  • by andy