Show pageOld revisionsBacklinksBack to top This page is read only. You can view the source, but not change it. Ask your administrator if you think this is wrong. {{tag>sacred_texts}} ====== The Book of Lies (Liber CCCXXXIII) ====== <WRAP right 260px> {{:0:literature:book-of-lies-title-1913.png?250|Title page of the 1913 first edition of The Book of Lies, published by Wieland and Co.}} //Title page of the 1913 first edition of The Book of Lies, published by Wieland and Co.// [[https://iapsop.com/ssoc/1913__crowley___liber_cccxxxiii_the_book_of_lies.pdf|Source and original]]. **Public domain.** </WRAP> //The Book of Lies//, Liber CCCXXXIII or 333, is a collection of brief paradoxes, poems, jokes, symbolic passages and ritual texts first published in 1913. The full title undermines itself by describing the book as falsely called //Breaks// and referring to the falsifications of a thought that is itself untrue. This is a signal about language and standpoint, not merely an announcement that the reader should distrust every sentence in the same way.(([[https://iapsop.com/ssoc/1913__crowley___liber_cccxxxiii_the_book_of_lies.pdf|The Book of Lies]], original 1913 edition, title and text.)) ===== Form and classification ===== The original imprimatur designates Classes C and D and calls the book official for Babes of the Abyss. The combination is significant: some passages are suggestive or interpretive, while others provide ritual directions. The whole collection should not be treated as one homogeneous manual. Its short chapters use titles, numbers, typography, sound and allusion as well as ordinary exposition. A paragraph that seems trivial can depend on a numerical relationship or on its place beside another chapter. Conversely, not every joke needs to be expanded into an elaborate cipher to be worth reading. The fractured form suits a work that repeatedly challenges confidence in fixed intellectual positions. The reader is asked to notice not only what a proposition says but what happens when its standpoint changes. ==== The opening punctuation pages ==== Before the first prose chapter, the original sequence gives a page to a question mark and then a page to an exclamation mark. Each stands alone within the heavy border used for the book's other entries. The page is part of the presentation: reducing the pair to punctuation in a continuous transcript loses the pause and isolation created by the layout. The pair can be compared with the questioning and assertion personified in [[the_soldier_and_the_hunchback|The Soldier and the Hunchback]]. That comparison is a reading aid; the facsimile establishes the order and appearance of these two pages without requiring one final interpretation of them.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/333/chapters-0-91_low.pdf|The Book of Lies]], opening punctuation pages (1913).)) <WRAP centeralign> {{:0:literature:book-of-lies-question-1913.png?260|The first opening punctuation page of The Book of Lies (1913): a question mark.}} </WRAP> //The first opening punctuation page of The Book of Lies (1913): a question mark.// [[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/333/chapters-0-91_low.pdf|Source and original]]. **Public domain:** original published 1913. Click to enlarge. <WRAP centeralign> {{:0:literature:book-of-lies-exclamation-1913.png?260|The following opening page: an exclamation mark within the same border.}} </WRAP> //The following opening page: an exclamation mark within the same border.// [[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/333/chapters-0-91_low.pdf|Source and original]]. **Public domain:** original published 1913. Click to enlarge. ===== Why “lies”? ===== One recurring problem is the inadequacy of a limited statement to express what exceeds its terms. A sentence distinguishes one thing from another; the mystical states discussed in the book challenge that very division. A statement can be useful at one level and misleading when promoted to an absolute description. Chapter 24 identifies the problem as a translation between unlike modes: > This book would translate Beyond-Reason into the words of Reason. — Aleister Crowley, //The Book of Lies//.(([[https://iapsop.com/ssoc/1913__crowley___liber_cccxxxiii_the_book_of_lies.pdf|The Book of Lies]], chapter 24, “The Hawk and the Blindworm”, 1913 edition, p. 33.)) Its ensuing remarks concede that ordinary language can appear misused in the attempt. The chapter praises silence, then qualifies silence in turn, so it never settles on the simple solution of refusing all speech. The reader encounters successive limits within one miniature composition. This is a more precise account of its paradox than saying merely that the author intends to deceive. This does not mean ordinary accuracy is irrelevant. Dates, wording and ritual variants remain checkable. The book's philosophical treatment of limitation should not become an excuse to invent facts about its contents or publication. Chapter 39 makes the reader’s relation to the words part of their meaning: > But without that Experience these words are the Lies of a Looby. — Aleister Crowley, //The Book of Lies//.(([[https://iapsop.com/ssoc/1913__crowley___liber_cccxxxiii_the_book_of_lies.pdf|The Book of Lies]], chapter 39, “The Looby”, 1913 edition, p. 50.)) The demonstrative “that” refers back to the experience the chapter has just described as emerging through use. Quoting a contradiction is therefore insufficient on the chapter’s own terms. Its final joke then shifts the judgement again among “thee”, “me” and God. This change of audience continues the collection’s concern with standpoint while keeping the comic voice audible. The passage states Crowley’s account of experience; it does not independently establish his accompanying claim about a new function of the brain. ===== Several kinds of chapter ===== ^ Form ^ What to notice ^ | Epigram or paradox | The assumptions that make the statement appear true or false. | | Poem or visionary image | Repetition, sound, personification and changes of speaker. | | Joke or pun | How several meanings of a word operate at once. | | Numbered symbolic passage | The relation between title, chapter number and content. | | Ritual instruction | The actual version, sequence and ceremonial vocabulary. | These are reading categories, not separate divisions printed in the book. A chapter can participate in more than one. The variety is part of the work's construction rather than an accidental collection of unrelated scraps. ===== Skidoo and the problem of departure ===== Chapter 23, “Skidoo”, repeatedly tells the reader to get out, playing on the relation between being inside, initiation and departure. The verbal insistence is part of the argument: becoming an initiate is not the same as reaching a comfortable stopping point. Letter play enters the same short passage. This is a useful example of how the work combines ordinary speech, symbolic construction and a challenge to the reader's position. A prose explanation can clarify the mechanism without replacing the rhythmic force of the original. ===== Caviar: a miniature sequence of attainment ===== Chapter 6, **Caviar**, begins with a Word expanding into an immense multiplicity of worlds and things. It then follows different responses to a small selection from that multiplicity. The reasoner mistakes a selection for a complete explanation; the Adept harmonises it; the Master of the Temple destroys it and remains silent; the Magus produces the Word from its ashes. The final reference to the Ipsissimus returns the reader to nothingness.((//The Book of Lies//, chapter 6, “Caviar”, 1913 text.)) The succession gives the short chapter a definite movement. It does not merely announce that thinking is bad or that every assertion is equally mistaken. Analysis, harmony, dissolution and utterance occupy different places in a symbolic account of attainment. The reader can compare this condensed literary sequence with the fuller grade descriptions in [[one_star_in_sight|One Star in Sight]], while allowing for their different purposes. ===== The Branks: grammar as a model of limitation ===== Chapter 9, **The Branks**, takes the parts of speech as its material. Nouns, adjectives and verbs become models for being, form and movement; other grammatical categories are associated with time, space and relationships. Language does not merely describe a world already divided into things: in the chapter's argument, its organisation participates in the way those divisions are made.((//The Book of Lies//, chapter 9, “The Branks”.)) The chapter then asks for the destruction of the grammatical framework and finally of the remaining cry. Even the apparent escape from discursive speech is not treated as a final possession. This is one way the collection enacts its title: an explanation may reveal something while also establishing a new boundary that must be recognised. Read together, the two chapters demonstrate the variety within the collection's method. Caviar arranges initiatory responses into a sequence; The Branks dismantles the categories through which a response is expressed. Neither can be adequately represented by extracting a single maxim from its ending. The changes within each miniature composition carry much of the argument, just as gestures and successive actions carry the argument of the ritual chapters. ===== Rituals within the collection ===== Chapter 25 contains [[the_star_ruby|The Star Ruby]], chapter 36 [[the_star_sapphire|The Star Sapphire]], and chapter 44 [[mass_of_the_phoenix|The Mass of the Phoenix]]. These chapters explain why the collection matters to practical ritual study as well as literature.((//The Book of Lies//, chapters 25, 36 and 44.)) Version matters. The 1913 Star Ruby has divine names that differ from the later presentation in //Magick in Theory and Practice//. An editor should not silently combine them or treat one as a transcription error merely because it differs from a familiar modern copy. The Star Sapphire's compressed language also presupposes specialised knowledge. Its inclusion does not make the whole volume a course designed to be performed chapter by chapter. The relation between a ritual and neighbouring philosophical material requires interpretation, not an assumption that all passages have identical practical status. ===== Commentary and publication history ===== The original edition and later editions with commentary are different reading experiences. The 1919 Præmonstrance advertises a version with an extended commentary, demonstrating the importance Crowley attached to interpreting the terse original. An advertised intention, however, should not be mistaken for a complete publication history.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/3.1/praemonstrance-of-aa_low.pdf|Præmonstrance of A∴A∴]], p. 14.)) Commentary can identify allusions and numerical constructions, but it should be cited as commentary. The distinction is especially helpful when an interpretation sounds more explicit than anything actually stated in the short chapter. Original typography and diagrams should also be checked against a scan rather than trusted to optical character recognition. ===== Reading the book in context ===== Read a small group of chapters, retaining their titles and numbers, before consulting explanations. Then compare the proposed reading with the actual words. This keeps commentary from becoming a substitute for the text and reduces the temptation to force every passage into a single doctrine. [[little_essays_toward_truth|Little Essays Toward Truth]] offers more discursive treatments of knowledge, silence and truth. [[liber_aleph|Liber Aleph]] also uses short chapters but sustains an extended instructional voice. Their formal differences help explain the particular effects of //The Book of Lies//. ===== Video: reading selected chapters of The Book of Lies ===== IAO131 discusses the title page, publication classes and selected chapters of //The Book of Lies// in this Thelemic Union presentation. The chapter markers identify discussions of “O!” at 4:43, “The Oyster” at 12:36 and “Steeped Horsehair” at 19:56. These selections offer worked examples of contemporary interpretation to compare with the article's account of paradox, imagery and commentary. {{ youtube>wcj0twshMkQ?full |Understanding Aleister Crowley's The Book of Lies}} **Understanding Aleister Crowley's The Book of Lies** — [[https://www.youtube.com/@ThelemicUnion|Thelemic Union]]; 27:49. [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wcj0twshMkQ|Watch on YouTube]]. ===== Sources and further reading ===== * [[https://iapsop.com/ssoc/1913__crowley___liber_cccxxxiii_the_book_of_lies.pdf|The Book of Lies]], original 1913 scan. * [[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/3.1/praemonstrance-of-aa_low.pdf|1919 announcement of the commented edition]]. * [[the_star_ruby|The Star Ruby]]; [[the_star_sapphire|The Star Sapphire]]; [[mass_of_the_phoenix|The Mass of the Phoenix]]. Last modified: 2026/10/04 14:49by andy Log In