====== Dharana in Crowley’s System ====== {{:0:literature:dharana-book4-1912.png?250|Opening of the chapter on dharana, Book 4, Part I (1912), p. 55.}} //Opening of the chapter on dharana, Book 4, Part I (1912), p. 55.// [[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/book4/1/dharana_low.pdf|Source and original]]. **Public domain.** **Dharana** is the sustained concentration of attention on a single object in Aleister Crowley’s sequence of mental training. Chapter V of [[book_4|Book 4, Part I]] (1912) examines the difficulty of holding that object unchanged, the interruptions that occur, and the interpretation of a practice record. It follows [[pratyahara|pratyahara]], which develops observation of mental activity, and precedes the account of [[dhyana|dhyana]] as a result of concentration.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/book4/1/dharana_low.pdf|Book 4, Part I, “Dharana”]], pp. 55–60.)) The chapter’s detail is significant. Crowley does not treat concentration as an ability proved by simply declaring an intention to focus. He describes failures of attention as material for examination and distinguishes several kinds of interruption that a crude total would conceal. ===== An object rather than an interesting subject ===== Crowley begins by distinguishing dharana from ordinary interest in a complicated subject. Someone can remain absorbed in a problem while moving freely between related ideas. That movement may make the interest easier to sustain. Dharana instead attempts to hold one simple object steady.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/book4/1/dharana_low.pdf|“Dharana”]], pp. 55–56.)) The distinction changes the meaning of success. Thinking about meditation, discussing the symbolism of an image or following a sequence of associations is not the same task as maintaining the image itself without alteration. A sustained theme may therefore coexist with repeated changes in the actual object of attention. His mechanical analogies convey the contrast between stability supported by movement and the harder task of stillness. Their role is explanatory. The chapter’s real test concerns what the mind does when variety and elaboration are deliberately limited. ===== The instability of the imagined object ===== The principal example is a white cross. Crowley lists the ways its imagined appearance may change: proportions, orientation, colour, brightness, distance, additional markings and complete replacement. The detail shows that interruption is not limited to an obvious switch to an unrelated topic. The supposed object can change while still being vaguely recognised as the same thing.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/book4/1/dharana_low.pdf|“Dharana”]], p. 56.)) The student may also lose the object altogether and only later notice that attention has wandered. Crowley interprets recognition of this difficulty as the beginning of a more accurate understanding of the exercise. Early confidence can reflect a failure to observe what has been happening. This makes dharana continuous with the preceding discussion of pratyahara. In both chapters, increased awareness can initially produce a less flattering account of performance. The practical problem is not simply a lack of willpower; it also concerns how the student recognises and describes a lapse. ===== Time, breaks and the practice record ===== The chapter places a notebook, pencil and watch beside the student. Its account carefully distinguishes the duration of an attempt from uninterrupted success: > By “keeping to it at all” is meant the mere attempt to keep to it. — Aleister Crowley, //Book 4, Part I//.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/book4/1/dharana_low.pdf|Book 4, Part I]], chapter V, “Dharana,” p. 57.)) A session lasting several minutes must not be mistaken for several minutes of perfect concentration. Crowley invokes Frater P.’s record, with four-minute meditations still appearing after six months of daily practice. Duration needs to be read alongside the interruptions and conditions documented in the entry.((//Book 4, Part I//, “Dharana,” pp. 57–58.)) The text also limits the beginner’s session length and notes fatigue and adverse conditions. This is a useful qualification to an account that portrays the programme solely as ever-increasing endurance. The chapter recognises that the conditions of an attempt affect the meaning of its outcome. An increasing number of recorded breaks does not necessarily prove deterioration. Observation may have improved. Conversely, fewer obvious interruptions do not establish perfectly continuous concentration: subtler flickering may remain undetected. A [[magical_record|record]] therefore requires interpretation as well as counting. Crowley gives physical tiredness and other immediate conditions as reasons why one session may differ from another. The record’s value is its ability to make such differences visible, rather than to turn every variation into a major spiritual event. ===== The classification of interruptions ===== The final pages classify breaks by character as well as number. This provides a second way to assess change. Two sessions with the same total interruptions may differ in the kinds of distraction that dominate.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/book4/1/dharana_low.pdf|“Dharana”]], pp. 59–60.)) ^ Kind of break ^ Description in the chapter ^ | Bodily sensation | Physical demands that the preliminary work of asana is intended to reduce | | Recent impressions | Thoughts prompted by events immediately before the session | | Reverie | Daydreaming that may continue unnoticed for some time | | Commentary on the practice | Thoughts about success, improved surroundings or the exercise itself | | Apparently unprompted phenomena | Material whose source is not readily recognised, including occasional auditory experiences | The fourth category is especially revealing. A thought congratulating the student on excellent concentration interrupts the very concentration it praises. Imagining a more suitable location can work in the same way. Such thoughts remain close to the subject of practice while departing from its actual object. Crowley does not automatically identify unusual auditory phenomena as supernatural communication. He discusses them as interruptions and explicitly distinguishes recognising a hallucination from mistaking it for an unquestionable message. Their occurrence is not, in itself, the attainment the chapter seeks. ===== Change in the pattern of breaks ===== The first two classes above—bodily sensations and recent impressions—are called primary and secondary breaks. Crowley expects their share of the total to change: > As control improves, the percentage of primaries and secondaries will diminish, even though the total number of breaks in a meditation remain stationary. — Aleister Crowley, //Book 4, Part I//.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/book4/1/dharana_low.pdf|Book 4, Part I]], chapter V, “Dharana,” p. 60.)) An unchanged total can conceal a different distribution. The practice record therefore needs descriptions of the interruptions as well as a count. This adds a qualitative dimension to the earlier question of whether improved observation is revealing previously unnoticed lapses. The categories are part of his proposed method of examining practice; they are not a validated clinical classification of attention. Their historical importance is that they encourage a more specific description than simply calling a session good or bad. The chapter also discusses episodes of discontinuity in which the student momentarily loses the ordinary sense of identity or circumstance. Crowley interprets these within his mystical framework. Their strangeness should be distinguished from a settled explanation of their cause or significance. ==== Observation and control in the preceding chapter ==== The diagram in Book 4's preceding chapter on pratyahara provides a useful companion to the changing pattern of breaks. It compares observation, control and the student's dissatisfaction. The plotted relationship explains how noticing more mental events can alter one's assessment of progress. This is Crowley's explanatory diagram from the pratyahara chapter, not a graph of the dharana categories or a set of measured experimental results. The distinction matters: the later discussion quoted above concerns the distribution of particular kinds of interruption, whereas the diagram concerns the relationship between observing and controlling the mind.(([[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/book4/1/pratyahara_low.pdf|Book 4, Part I, Pratyahara]], p. 49.)) {{:0:literature:book4_attention-1912.png?520|Crowley’s explanatory diagram in Book 4, Part I, Pratyahara (1912), p. 49.}} //Crowley’s explanatory diagram in Book 4, Part I, Pratyahara (1912), p. 49.// [[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/book4/1/pratyahara_low.pdf|Source and original]]. **Public domain:** original published 1912. Click to enlarge. ===== From concentration to dhyana ===== The final transition introduces another kind of interruption: the result sought by the exercise itself. The next chapter takes up [[dhyana|dhyana]], where Crowley describes a change in the relation between observer and observed. This is why dharana cannot simply be used as an interchangeable label for every mystical experience. The relation also explains the preparatory role of [[asana|asana]] and [[pranayama|pranayama]]. They reduce competing demands so that the task of attention can be examined more clearly. [[liber_e|Liber E]], particularly its section on dharana, supplies a more formal series of related exercises, while //Book 4// explains their difficulties and intended development. ===== Video: concentration and the practice record ===== David Shoemaker introduces dharana and its place in meditation from about [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hBQgUlTgtwg&t=100s|1:40]] in this Living Thelema programme. The discussion turns to practical concentration methods around [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hBQgUlTgtwg&t=320s|5:20]], including holding an object of attention and recording interruptions. These subjects closely complement the article's treatment of breaks, observation and the interpretation of apparent progress. {{ youtube>hBQgUlTgtwg?full |Living Thelema - Meditation and Visualization Practices}} **Living Thelema - Meditation and Visualization Practices** — [[https://www.youtube.com/@speechinthesilence|Speech in the Silence Podcast]]; 33:35. [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hBQgUlTgtwg|Watch on YouTube]]. ===== Sources ===== * [[https://keepsilence.org/the-equinox/book4/1/dharana_low.pdf|Original chapter on dharana]], //Book 4, Part I// (1912), pp. 55–60. * [[https://www.bibliotecapleyades.net/crowley/liber/libers/Liber9.pdf|Liber E vel Exercitiorum]], sections I and V. {{tag>magical_practices}}