Table of Contents

Set (Seth)

Scarab showing winged Seth-Baal, about 1300–1080 BCE. Metropolitan Museum of Art, 22.1.392.

Scarab showing winged Seth-Baal, about 1300–1080 BCE. Metropolitan Museum of Art, 22.1.392. Source and original. Public domain. Rights information (CC0).

Set, also written Seth, is an Egyptian deity associated with conflict, disruptive force and dangerous protective power. He participates in the struggle over Osiris's succession, but also appears as a defender of the solar god against Apophis. Those contrasting functions make a simple identification with the Christian devil inadequate.

Conflict and succession

In the Heliopolitan genealogy Seth belongs to the generation of Osiris, Isis and Nephthys, the children of Geb and Nut. Accounts of Osiris's death and Horus's claim to kingship place Seth in conflict with the younger claimant. The surviving traditions vary in their episodes and resolutions; they do not form a single continuous account written at one time.1)

The struggle concerns legitimate succession as well as physical power. This helps explain why divine arbitration is part of its imagery. Thoth and other gods can have coordinating or judicial roles, while the rivalry itself becomes a way to represent contested authority.

A protector against Apophis

Seth's force can defend the sun against the serpent Apophis, or Apep. The same deity who threatens order in one narrative helps preserve it in another. The distinction is essential: Seth and Apophis are not interchangeable names.2)

This ambivalence is more informative than a division of all Egyptian gods into permanently good and evil camps. The relevant question is what a deity does in a particular scene: who is opposed, what is protected, and how the action relates to divine or royal order. Protective power need not be gentle to be protective.

Seth-Baal and an ancient seal

A small scarab in the Metropolitan Museum, dated about 1300–1080 BCE, depicts winged Seth-Baal. The carved figure has an extended wing and the characteristic head, with a cobra before him and a solar disk above. The catalogue relates this combined form to Seth's identification with the Near Eastern Baal and his importance in the Ramesside period.3)

The object provides ancient evidence for a combined divine identity. It is useful precisely because the attribution is specific: a particular seal, period and image. Ancient identifications between gods existed, but they do not automatically validate every later occult equation involving the same names.

Images that changed over time

A copper Seth figure included in the Met's Gifts for the Gods exhibition was altered in antiquity: its ears were removed and ram horns and a crown were added. The exhibition record also distinguishes nineteenth-century restorations from ancient changes.4)

Such alterations belong to the object's religious and collecting history. They caution against assuming that the appearance of a surviving figure is exactly what its first maker intended. Identification may depend on the record of changes as much as on the image now visible.

Typhon and modern magical interpretation

Crowley's Book of Thoth places Typhon among the figures of trump X, Fortune, with the Sphinx and Hermanubis. The discussion coordinates Egyptian and Greek names with a theory of recurring forces. It is a modern symbolic argument, not a catalogue of ancient cult practice.5)

Typhon on a turning wheel

In Fortune (X), The Book of Thoth places Typhon on the descending side of the wheel, opposite an ascending Hermanubis, with the Sphinx temporarily at the top. Crowley's explanation assigns the figures to changing alchemical conditions: Typhon to Salt, Hermanubis to Mercury and the Sphinx to Sulphur. He also compares the arrangement with the three gunas. The relations are dynamic; no figure permanently occupies the commanding position.6)

This makes the descending monster more than a static label for wickedness. Its place describes a phase in a process whose other conditions also change. The wheel's association with Jupiter concerns the unpredictable character of fortune, not a promise that every turn produces comfortable results. Crowley's Greek mythological account of Typhon belongs to this composite interpretation and should not be treated as a complete account of Egyptian Seth.

The image is consequently useful for studying how modern ceremonial symbolism combines materials. Greek myth, alchemical principles and an Indian classification enter one explanatory scheme. Recognising that construction allows its internal argument to be examined without projecting the entire arrangement back into a single ancient religion.

The explanation gives change priority over the temporary arrangement:

This card thus represents the Universe in its aspect as a continual change of state.

— Aleister Crowley, The Book of Thoth.7)

Crowley subsequently says that the Sphinx occupies the summit temporarily. Typhon’s descending position therefore belongs to a moving relation among three figures. The wheel cannot be read adequately as a permanent ranking of three beings. This is particularly relevant when Typhon is compared with Seth: the card’s alchemical use supplies one modern arrangement, not a complete account of Seth’s protective and antagonistic roles in Egyptian material.

Rivalry and royal union

Egyptian images also bring Horus and Seth together in support of kingship. The Global Egyptian Museum relates their paired appearance to the unification of the Two Lands. Their rivalry and their capacity to express a joined royal order are therefore both relevant to understanding the god.8)

A scene of cooperation does not erase narratives of conflict. It shows that the relationship could be used to represent an encompassing order as well as a dispute within it. Asking what the pair does in a particular royal or funerary scene produces a fuller reading than assigning one god an invariably positive and the other an invariably negative meaning.

Set and Typhon in the signs of the grades

The plate accompanying Liber O supplies a more specific ceremonial comparison. Its Earth sign names Set fighting, while the L.V.X. sequence includes Typhon among the figures associated with the drama of Osiris. The same publication therefore uses related Egyptian and Greek names in two different arrangements: an elemental series and a ritual account of death and restoration.9)

In the keyword analysis, Isis, Apophis and Osiris are coordinated with the letters I.A.O. and their respective signs. This is ceremonial construction: the sequence gives the names and postures a role in the explanation of a formula. It should not be read as a straightforward translation of one ancient Egyptian narrative. The text itself is the evidence for this particular combination.

The example also prevents the label “Typhonian” from becoming too vague. It can describe a reference within Crowley's inherited ritual material or a much more extensive later system, such as the work of Kenneth Grant. The presence of the name alone does not identify which body of teaching is intended.

The Earth gesture is described through an asymmetrical stance:

Advance the right foot, stretch out the right hand upwards and forwards, the left hand downwards and backwards, the palms open.

— Aleister Crowley, Liber O vel Manus et Sagittae.10)

Its two hands extend in opposed directions, matching the fighting figure named in the accompanying grade-sign plate. The same printed page later describes the Apophis and Typhon sign with both arms raised above the head. Reading the instructions side by side prevents a loose association of the names from collapsing two distinct gestures. The difference is visible in the body positions as well as in their ceremonial settings.

Two gestures in the original plate

The numbered photographs make the distinction visible. Figure 1, at the bottom, is labelled Earth and Set fighting. Figure 9, third from the left in the top row, is Typhon within the L.V.X. sequence. Its raised arms form the V that the caption associates with the trident. The opposing extensions of figure 1 should therefore not be replaced with figure 9 merely because Set and Typhon are related names.

The complete plate is retained so that its numbers and explanatory key can be checked together. These are photographs illustrating modern ceremonial signs, not images offered as direct records of ancient Egyptian ritual.11)

The Signs of the Grades, Liber O (1909). Compare figure 1, Earth / Set fighting, with figure 9, V / Typhon, in the top row.

The Signs of the Grades, Liber O (1909). Compare figure 1, Earth / Set fighting, with figure 9, V / Typhon, in the top row. Source facsimile: Keep Silence. Public domain: original published in 1909. Click the image to enlarge.

Apep in a different literary setting

The distinction between Seth and Apep becomes especially useful when reading Liber LXV. At V:57, the speaker addresses the serpent Apep together with the beloved Lord Adonai. The verse follows the parable of a hummingbird, an ibis and a serpent, and turns toward the relation between a brief lifetime and eternity.12)

The address is striking because Apep is an adversarial figure in Egyptian solar mythology. Here the name participates in a sacred poem of devotion and transformation. This is a concrete instance of Crowley's ability to change a symbol's religious function. It would be misleading either to replace Apep with Seth or to infer that all appearances of Apep in ancient sources express this devotional meaning.

The broader lesson concerns the scope of an interpretation. Ancient protective force, a grade sign and a visionary address are three different settings in which dangerous or disruptive imagery can appear. Their differences help explain the attraction of these figures to later occult writers without making one simplified definition govern them all.

Claims about Seth in later Thelemic or Typhonian writing should therefore identify the author and work involved. Neither Crowley's particular Tarot interpretation nor an ancient combined form such as Seth-Baal can stand for every later usage. See Kenneth Grant, Horus and Egyptian gods and Thelemic adaptations for related subjects.

3)
Scarab with Figure of Winged Seth-Baal, Metropolitan Museum of Art, 22.1.392.
4)
Gifts for the Gods, Seth figure, Ny Carlsberg Glyptotek, AEIN 614.
5)
The Book of Thoth, “X. Fortune.”
6)
The Book of Thoth, Part II, “X. Fortune”, pp. 89–91.
7)
The Book of Thoth, part II, “X. Fortune” (1944), p. 90.
9)
Liber O, “The Signs of the Grades” and the analysis of the keyword.
10)
Liber O vel Manus et Sagittae, IV:1, Greater Ritual of the Pentagram, Earth sign; reprinted in Magick in Theory and Practice (1929), p. 382.
11)
Liber O, original plate “The Signs of the Grades,” The Equinox I:2 (1909).
12)
Liber LXV, V:51–59.