Table of Contents

,

The Sword of Song

Opening of The Sword of Song in Collected Works, volume II (1906).

Opening of The Sword of Song in Collected Works, volume II (1906). Source and original. Public domain.

The Sword of Song, subtitled “Called by Christians the Book of the Beast”, is Crowley's 1904 collection of polemical verse and prose. It centres on the poems “Ascension Day” and “Pentecost”, accompanied by extensive notes and essays. The work is dedicated to Bhikkhu Ananda Metteyya, Allan Bennett.1)

A deliberately unstable title

The preliminary dialogue adapts the exchange between Alice and the White Knight in Through the Looking-Glass. It distinguishes the work, its name, the name of its title and what people call it, accumulating alternative descriptions until the attempt at clarification becomes comic. This is an apt introduction to a book that repeatedly questions the security of names, authorities and explanations.2)

The invocation “Nothung”, named for Siegfried's sword, then presents song as a weapon against established religious error. The book's literary form joins argument with ridicule, theatrical self-presentation and changes of register.

The invocation makes injury and remedy parts of the same poetic action:

Awake to wound, awake to heal

By wounding, thou resistless sword!

Raise the prone priestcrafts that appeal

In agony to their prostrate Lord!

— Aleister Crowley, The Sword of Song.3)

The repeated “awake” addresses the song as a weapon whose work has yet to begin. “Heal / By wounding” gives the attack a claimed restorative purpose, while the doubled posture of priestcraft and its Lord makes the reversal of religious authority visible. This is the rhetoric of the poem’s speaker. It establishes the aggressive literary stance through which the subsequent arguments are performed, without requiring the reader to accept the speaker’s judgement of his opponents.

Literal belief and interpretation

The prose introduction attacks both literal acceptance of religious claims and unrestricted allegorical reinterpretation. In Crowley's argument, the latter can turn a religion into a screen onto which an interpreter projects personal convictions. The problem is therefore not solved merely by replacing a literal reading with a symbolic one.4)

The poems and their annotations should be read together. The notes extend the debate through further argument, references and satire; they are part of the work's structure rather than only a modern editor's explanation.

Browning, parody and religious argument

The two central poems deliberately answer Robert Browning's “Christmas-Eve and Easter-Day”. Crowley's introduction acknowledges the borrowing in title, style and subject, and expresses admiration for Browning even while disputing the direction of his religious argument. Parody here is a form of engagement with a respected predecessor rather than simply the dismissal of an inferior writer.5)

Crowley is concerned with the point at which reasoning is permitted to question a religious belief and the point at which the believer decides it must stop. His discussion of Browning's Bishop Blougram focuses on the fear that removing one doubtful element may set a process in motion whose conclusion cannot be controlled. For Crowley, intellectual consistency demands that cherished conclusions be exposed to the same inquiry as everything else.

The introduction places this dispute beside other literary examples, including Shelley and Milton. These references make the poems part of an argument about what poetry can do with religion. Beauty may communicate an idea powerfully, but it may also absorb the reader's attention so completely that an uncomfortable implication goes unnoticed. Crowley's deliberately abrasive and comic passages try to keep argument and provocation audible within the poetry.

Ascension Day: doubt as a weapon

“Ascension Day” opens in the aftermath of a departure from chapel and moves through questions about truth, authority and rival explanations of life. Its mixture of learned allusion, mock self-presentation and polemical attack makes the speaker an active participant in the controversy. He does not occupy an anonymous position outside it. The margins and notes frequently comment on the speaker's own performance.6)

The sword image presents song as something that can cut through established error. Yet the book's humour also turns back upon the confidence and vanity of its own speaker. A reader has to follow the argument while recognising its theatrical exaggerations. The subtitle “Called by Christians the Book of the Beast” similarly makes an identity out of an adversary's supposed description. It is a provocative authorial pose, not a neutral classification of the work's contents.

The dedication reinforces this mixture. It honours Ananda Metteyya and then addresses the opponents whose attempts to obstruct the book are said to have helped it. Gratitude and insult share the same page. The reproduced opening from the 1906 Collected Works shows this feature of the original presentation, alongside the preliminary joke about the book's several names.

Pentecost: from an impasse to practice

“Pentecost” moves through the speaker's encounter with yoga and the problem of what to do when competing theories have failed to settle the questions that matter. The account of instruction is comic, including the pupil's discomfort and impatience, but the poem's practical turn is serious. A different way of knowing is sought because ordinary argument repeatedly reaches an impasse.7)

The poem contrasts labels such as “spiritual” and “material” with the conditions under which thinking actually takes place. It asks the reader to investigate rather than assume that a familiar division has solved the problem. In the discussion of the soul and impermanence, the speaker treats personal identity and thought themselves as objects of inquiry. The inquiry does not leave the inquirer safely outside its scope.

Everyday life remains present amid these arguments. The speaker refers to poetry, climbing, affection and the conduct of people encountered while travelling. This prevents the poem's practical question from being confined to an abstract contest between doctrines. How a person lives, what a person can sustain and what an experience changes become part of the assessment. Crowley's judgments of particular religions and peoples should, however, remain his judgments; their presence in the poem does not establish the generalisations as historical fact.

The work performed by notes and margins

The book's notes are unusually extensive and should be distinguished from an editor's modern apparatus. Crowley uses annotation to continue arguments, introduce examples, pursue a joke or shift into prose exposition. The margin may describe the movement of a passage in a tone different from that of the main verse. Reading only the poem while skipping these elements can therefore remove part of its intended interplay of voices.8)

This construction also explains why a short excerpt can be misleading. A seemingly settled pronouncement may be qualified, mocked or extended nearby. The text repeatedly places an assertion beside another perspective on that assertion. Its instability is deliberate, although that does not make every contradiction disappear into a single final system.

Agnosticism and the possibility of discovery

“After Agnosticism” distinguishes a continuing standard of inquiry from its present conclusions:

For this is my position; while the postulates of Agnosticism are in one sense eternal, I believe that the conclusions of Agnosticism are daily to be pushed back.

— Aleister Crowley, The Sword of Song.9)

Crowley announces this position through the joke of an invited contributor attacking his hosts. The joke prepares a serious distinction: admitting that something is not known does not determine that it can never be investigated. The phrase “daily to be pushed back” makes ignorance a changing boundary. This develops the practical turn of the poems while retaining the demand that a proposed advance be more than an unsupported assertion.

The associated “Initiated Interpretation of Ceremonial Magic” asks how ritual phenomena relate to perception and the brain. It neither requires a reader to begin with an unquestioned external spirit-world nor simply dismisses every experience as unworthy of examination. This conjunction of sceptical challenge and proposed practice helps connect the collection with Crowley's later formulation of Scientific Illuminism.

The 1904 first publication, 1906 collected printing and later electronic editions are separate witnesses to the work. The image in this article is from the collected printing; the familiar date 1904 printed at its head identifies the work's original date. Modern transcriptions can add editorial notes or arrange the prose material differently. Identify the printing and the named section when citing a passage, especially one encountered in a separate essay PDF.

The Collected Works-based text linked here includes Science and Buddhism, “After Agnosticism” and “The Initiated Interpretation of Ceremonial Magic”. 10)

The latter essay also appears in the 1904 Goetia, making it a useful connection between this literary collection and Crowley's presentation of ceremonial magic. Compare Scientific Illuminism and The Soldier and the Hunchback for later formulations of the relationship between scepticism and practice. Check an edition's contents before assuming that every separate PDF includes all the prose material.

1)
Aleister Crowley, The Sword of Song, title, dedication and contents; the linked transcription follows the Collected Works printing.
2)
The Sword of Song, opening dialogue.
3)
The Sword of Song, “Nothung”, fourth stanza, Collected Works II (1906), p. 141.
4)
The Sword of Song, “Introduction to Ascension Day and Pentecost”.
5)
The Sword of Song, “Introduction to Ascension Day and Pentecost”, especially the closing paragraphs.
6)
The Sword of Song, “Ascension Day” and its marginal summaries.
7)
The Sword of Song, “Pentecost”, especially the passages on the teacher, yoga and the necessities of thought.
8)
The Sword of Song, original presentation in Collected Works, volume II, 1906.
9)
The Sword of Song, “After Agnosticism”, Collected Works II (1906), p. 206.
10)
The Sword of Song, named prose sections.