The Four Fives in the Thoth Tarot

Why should the Five of Wands be Strife if Fire is in a fire sign? A sign tells only part of the story. Five belongs to Geburah and introduces movement into the order established by Four. In the first decan of Leo, Saturn gives that movement something to push against. Crowley argues that disturbance itself need not be judged evil. The four cards show four different consequences of it.

All four correspond to Geburah. They occupy 0° up to (but not including) 10° in the signs shown. The 1912 titles are from the printed inventory; the earth suit there is Pentacles.

Suit 1912 inventory title 1944 Thoth title Planet in sign
Wands Strife Strife Saturn in Leo
Cups Loss in Pleasure Disappointment Mars in Scorpio
Swords Defeat Defeat Venus in Aquarius
Disks Material Trouble Worry Mercury in Taurus

Saturn in Leo follows the Completion of the Four of Wands. The new sign matters: this is fixed Fire, and the title Strife survives unchanged from 1912 to 1944. Energy is plentiful, but its presence does not mean the competing forces can act together.

Loss in Pleasure becomes Disappointment. Compare the Four of Cups, where the cups were already full: Mars in Scorpio interrupts the expectation that satisfaction will last. The older title identifies the particular thing lost; the later one names the experience of that loss.

The name Defeat is the same in both inventories. In Crowley's sequence the armed peace of the Four of Swords cannot be maintained; the quarrel has broken out. Venus in Aquarius does not cancel that result. A favourable association for a planet in isolation cannot decide the title of a card.

Material Trouble becomes Worry. Mercury in Taurus brings a disturbance into the most settled of the elements. Crowley illustrates the card with a breakdown of economic balance; the change of title draws attention to what material trouble does to those living through it.

Ultimate success or failure is otherwise shewn.

— “A Description of the Cards of the Tarot”, The Equinox I:8 (1912), p. 176, note on the Fives.

1912 note on the Fives and four inventory entries with their titles and planetary and zodiacal signs.

Detail from the public-domain 1912 printing: the text on the Fives appears above the four entries from the inventory, pp. 148–149. The suit labels at left have been added; the numbered lines and glyphs are from the original.

For Crowley's later interpretation, see The Book of Thoth (1944), part IV, “The Four Fives”, pp. 180–181. For the difference between a rank attribution and a planetary ruler, see The Thirty-Six Decans in Tarot.

Fours · Index of all 36 cards · Sixes

You could leave a comment if you were logged in.
  • Last modified: 2026/11/08 18:05
  • by andy