Swords in the Thoth Tarot
In the Thoth pack Swords belong to Air and, in Crowley’s commentary, to the intellect. Their points can meet, cross, shatter a flower or come to rest within it. The suit includes Peace, Truce and Science alongside Sorrow and Ruin. A reading that treats the appearance of any sword as a prediction of conflict loses the distinctions the pictures make.
The fate of a rose
Crowley’s account of the Two places two swords across one another:
they are united by a blue rose with five petals.
— Aleister Crowley, The Book of Thoth (1944), part IV, “The Small Cards”, PDF p. 29.
Peace belongs to the Moon in Libra. Its stillness is an equilibrium between forces that can change. The Three retains Libra but places it under Saturn. In Crowley’s description, the rose that held the two weapons together is destroyed. In the Four, Jupiter in Libra, the four points rest in a much larger rose. The new title is Truce: an arrangement maintained by convention, rather than the original balance restored. Following the flower connects three pictures without making Peace and Truce synonyms.
The nine decan cards
| Card | Thoth title | Planet in sign |
|---|---|---|
| 2 | Peace | Moon in Libra |
| 3 | Sorrow | Saturn in Libra |
| 4 | Truce | Jupiter in Libra |
| 5 | Defeat | Venus in Aquarius |
| 6 | Science | Mercury in Aquarius |
| 7 | Futility | Moon in Aquarius |
| 8 | Interference | Jupiter in Gemini |
| 9 | Cruelty | Mars in Gemini |
| 10 | Ruin | Sun in Gemini |
The rows within each sign follow its first, second and third ten-degree sectors. See The Thirty-Six Decans in Tarot.
Comparing a Marseille pip
Three of Swords in Jean Dodal’s pack. A straight central blade lies between curved outer swords; the card does not carry Crowley’s title Sorrow. Source and original. Jean Dodal, Lyon, early eighteenth century. Bibliothèque nationale de France, via Wikimedia Commons. Public domain.
Look first at the central blade and the spaces made by the outer pair. Those features identify a composition a reader can compare across decks. The decisive change in the Thoth account is the treatment of the rose. Crowley makes a particular symbolic argument out of the interaction between blades and flower. It is not necessary to read that argument back into Dodal’s card, or to import a pierced human heart from a different tarot tradition.
Peace, truce and a broken settlement
The 1912 inventory distinguishes Peace restored, the Two, from Rest from Strife, the Four. Crowley makes the distinction sharper in 1944. He drops “restored” because no earlier numbered Sword has disturbed the peace. The Four, now Truce, concerns a settlement that can be broken. The quarrel actually breaks out at the Five, Defeat.
Follow the Two, Four and Five across the other suits. A second comparison is especially revealing: in the Six, the title Earned Success becomes Science. The sword that divided in earlier ranks here represents the mind bringing a problem into order.
Compare the 1912 inventory, pp. 148–149 with Crowley’s account of the ranks, pp. 177–188. The numbered-card index gives both sets of titles and links directly to all thirty-six cards.
Sources and related reading
- The Three and Four of Swords — Aleister Crowley, The Book of Thoth (1944), part IV, “The Small Cards”, PDF p. 30.
- The earlier Six of Swords, titled Earned Success — “A Description of the Cards of the Tarot”, The Equinox I:8 (1912), PDF p. 49.
Book T and the Golden Dawn Tarot · The Book of Thoth · Thoth Tarot.
