The Four Threes in the Thoth Tarot
The Threes raise a useful objection to the idea that an auspicious number must yield four cheerful cards. Binah, Understanding, gives the emerging idea a form. In one suit the result is Abundance; in another it is Sorrow. Both are consistent with the rank. The question is what has taken shape, and in which element.
The four cards side by side
All four correspond to Binah. They occupy 10° up to (but not including) 20° in the signs shown. The 1912 titles are from the printed inventory; the earth suit there is Pentacles.
Reading the Threes
Wands
Established Strength becomes Virtue. In the sequence of Aries, the Sun follows the Mars of Dominion. Crowley reads the Three as the point where an initial act of will becomes a quality of character. Virtue here is something will has learned to do consistently, rather than a general verdict on someone's morals.
Cups
Mercury in Cancer gives the Three of Cups its decan. The 1912 and 1944 titles agree: Abundance. Where the Two shows a relation between two vessels, three allows something to issue from that relation. The name directs attention to what the cups can now produce.
Swords
Saturn in Libra identifies Sorrow. Crowley links it to the darkness of Binah and the mourning of Isis; he explicitly distinguishes this sorrow from disappointment over a particular event. Read beside Abundance, the card shows how differently Water and Air express the same Understanding.
Disks
Material Works becomes Work. In Mars in Capricorn, effort begins to leave a result one can point to. The older plural emphasises products; Crowley's short title also leaves room for the activity that produces them. This is the middle decan of Capricorn, before the consolidation of the Four.
The 1912 evidence
Action definitely commenced for good or evil.
— “A Description of the Cards of the Tarot”, The Equinox I:8 (1912), p. 176, note on the Threes.
Detail from the public-domain 1912 printing: the text on the Threes appears above the four entries from the inventory, pp. 148–149. The suit labels at left have been added; the numbered lines and glyphs are from the original.
For Crowley's later interpretation, see The Book of Thoth (1944), part IV, “The Four Threes”, pp. 178–179. For the difference between a rank attribution and a planetary ruler, see The Thirty-Six Decans in Tarot.
